본문 바로가기

Validity in qualitative research after postcolonialism: Introducing post-oriental validity

문서 유형
연구출판물 · 학술지 논문
등재
ScopusSSCI
저널 순위
JCR Q2Scopus Q1
저널
EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY AND THEORY58(5) · pp.448 · 2026
피인용
Web of Science 3Scopus 2
FWCI (Scopus)
4.95
JCR IF
JCR 2024 1.8
ISSN
0013-1857

저자

  1. 정정훈제1저자Pusan Natl Univ, BK21 Educ Social Responsibil Res Program, Busan, South Korea
  2. Kim, Young Chun교신저자Chinju Natl Univ Educ, Dept Educ, Jinju, South Korea

초록

Drawing on broader postcolonial theories and critiques of established validity frameworks, this study introduces ‘Post-Oriental Validity’ as a framework designed specifically for evaluating qualitative research conducted in Asian contexts. It extends the existing discussion of validity claims by providing alternative and supplemental knowledge on validity theorization. Based on a content analysis of various qualitative research studies on Korea, this study proposes five new ideas of validity—Negative Representation Validity, Subaltern Validity, Hybridity Validity, Subversion Validity, and Abjection Validity—each addressing the limitations of existing concepts of validity and emphasizing the importance of cultural, historical, and epistemological contexts specific to non-Western societies. By developing the Post-Oriental Validity framework, this study enhances validity discourses in qualitative research by explicitly operationalizing epistemological pluralism and theoretical openness informed by, yet distinct from, traditional postcolonial critiques. It also offers practical insights for researchers seeking to design, conduct, and evaluate qualitative studies that reflect localized epistemologies and cultural specificities, thereby extending its relevance beyond Asian contexts.

키워드

post-oriental validitypostcolonial researchresearch as praxisValidity

식별자

Scopus EID
2-s2.0-105019383912
WoS UID
001595765500001