본문 바로가기

한국 간호 연구에서의 도구 번역 및 번안 과정:주제범위 문헌고찰

Instrument Translation and Adaptation Process in Korean Nursing Research: A Scoping Review

문서 유형
연구출판물 · 학술지 논문
등재
KCI
저널 순위
KCI Q3
피인용
KCI 0
ISSN
2233-5560

저자

  1. 황선경제1저자부산대학교 간호대학.간호과학연구소 교수
  2. 문희애교신저자부산대학교 간호대학 대학원생
  3. 조민은부산대학교 간호대학 대학원생

초록

This study aimed to examine the process of translating and adapting instruments for nursing research into Korean. Methods: Using the scoping review methods, a literature review was conducted independently by two reviewers. They searched the literature across two electronic databases (CINAHL and RISS), hand-searched nine major Korean nursing journals, and searched Google Scholar for grey literature. Results: A total of 130 articles were eligible for inclusion. Only 64.6% of the articles adhered to guidelines for cross-cultural translation and adaptation of instruments, indicating an increasing trend in compliance, but also highlighting instances of non-compliance or lack of explicit mention. Our analysis also revealed that 70.0% obtained permission from the original authors to use the instruments. In forward translation, 21.5% involved multiple bilingual translators, while 78.5% relied on a single translator or individuals with various qualifications. Only 16.2% of articles reported performing back translation with two bilingual translators. Concerning expert panels, only 5.4% included them, with 22.3% having insufficient panel composition. Pre-testing involved surveys with 10 or more participants in 43.1% of studies. Cognitive interviews were conducted in 16.2% of the studies. Finally, 99.2% reported the final translated version, and 49.2% documented changes made during the process. Conclusion: This review underscores the need for more standardized and rigorous approaches in the translation and adaptation of instruments for cross-cultural research in nursing in Korea. It calls for greater adherence to established guidelines, utilizing expert panels and cognitive interviewing, and thorough documentation to ensure the cross-cultural validation of research instruments.

키워드

Cross-cultural comparisonTranslationsNursing researchSurveys and questionnairesValidation study

식별자

KCI
ART003048998