본문 바로가기

사회정의: 자유주의적 정의론에 관한 인식을 중심으로

Social Justice: Cognition on Libertarian Perspective

문서 유형
연구출판물 · 학술지 논문
등재
KCI
저널 순위
KCI Q3
저널
제도와 경제15(1) · pp.107 · 2021
피인용
KCI 1
ISSN
1976-3697

저자

  1. 김행범제1저자부산대학교

초록

Francis Fukuyama needed to be more modest. A new spectre with cloak of ‘Social Justice’ came back and now rules over every socio-economic policies. Distribution by government is being identified with Social Justice. This paper extracts the Libertarian justice theories andstudies on notions of intellectuals on Libertarian justice arguments of Friedrich A. Hayek and Robert Nozick. Hayek’s justice arguments were categorized into 6 premises: Ontology, Epistemology, Personification, Desert Norm, Atavism. Nozick’s justice arguments as 6 premises: Just Acquisition, Just Transfer, Rectification of Injustice, Limitation of Holding, Minimal State, Natural Asset. Cognitions of those justice were measured among 3 groups: A(Students with some exposures to Libertarian classes), B(Ordinary, non-libertarian professors), C(Libertarian_professors). By MANOVA(multivariate analysis of variance), their cognition on Libertarian justice were tested. First, existing intuitive and qualitative analyses on Hayek and Nozick can be tested, supplemented and reinforced by the quantitative analysis. Second, Libertarian justice cognition is disproportionately revealed according to 3 groups. Third, Libertarian_professors show the highest cognition than Students and Ordinary_professors. Fourth, they have relatively more various views on Hayek than on Nozick. Fifth, among A, B and C groups, there are robust pattern of degree of cognition on Libertarian justice: B≤A<C. Sixth, for all groups Nozick’s justice premises are more perceived than Hayek’s. This research has some caveats. First, sample sizes need to be enlarged. Second, MANOVA’s ideal assumption of homogeneity of variances of dependent variables were not fully satisfied. Third, justice arguments from Hayek and Nozick may not be sufficient, leaving room for validity problem of scales. Finally, one thing seems to loom clear. Libertarian justice theory suggests that if anything like justice in true meaning exists, never it would be one which a political entity arbitrarily impose as justice for their political consideration. It is time to turn from dogmatic distributionist’s justice to other ones like libertarian notion of justice. What’s most important is not ‘Social Justice’, but ‘Just Justice’.

키워드

사회정의자유주의하이에크노직롤스다변량 분산분석.Social justiceLibertarianismHayekNozickRawlsMANOVA.

식별자

KCI
ART002687633