Gender differences in gifted elementary students' decision-making about renewable energy: Social relationships, values, and authority (RTP)
- 문서 유형
- 연구출판물 · 학술대회 발표논문
- 등재
- Scopus
- 저널
- ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, Conference Proceedings2020-June · 2020
- 피인용
- Scopus 1
- FWCI (Scopus)
- 0
- ISSN
- 2153-5965
저자
초록
This study examines how gender affected gifted elementary students' engineering-based argumentative practices and decision-making processes as they selected renewable energy sources to support South Korea's future. Twenty-one gifted elementary science students participated in four steps of the Jigsaw group discussion process: 1) single-gender group discussion before information was given, 2) single-gender group discussion after information was given, 3) mixed-gender group discussion as a format of expert group discussion, and 4) original single-gender group discussion. Videotaped group discussions and student worksheets were the primary data sources. Students' argumentative practices were investigated in two aspects: social negotiation patterns and reasoning. The social negotiation patterns of students' argumentative practice were analyzed using an analytic framework adapted from Toulmin's model of argument structure, and the collaborative reasoning patterns of students' argumentative practice were analyzed based on Walton's reasoning scheme. Then their decision-making process was analyzed using an analytical framework developed by the authors. Social negotiation pattern results show that girls' social negotiation was more affected by gender grouping (single or mixed) than boys. However, there was no significant gender difference in terms of collaborative reasoning. We identified critical factors that affected students' final decisions in each unit of discourse analysis. Girls' engineering decisions were safety-oriented, so they prioritized energy options with no known disadvantages even if other options had known advantages. In contrast, boys selected an option if they felt that they had collected sufficient evidence to reach consensus and did not select an option if it included economic disadvantages or technological limitations.
식별자
- Scopus EID
- 2-s2.0-85095721966



로그인
연구물 목록으로