본문 바로가기

경험주의적 문헌학과 이론적 해석학의 충돌: 2000년대 베케트 연구에서 발생한 펠드만-다우드 논쟁을 중심으로

A Clash between Empirical Philology and Theoretical Hermeneutics: Focusing on the Feldman-Dowd Dispute in Beckett Studies in the 2000s

문서 유형
연구출판물 · 학술지 논문
등재
KCI
저널
새한영어영문학61(3) · pp.73 · 2019
피인용
KCI 1
ISSN
1598-7124

저자

  1. 이주엽제1저자부산대학교

초록

This study casts light on the conflict between empirical philology and theoretical criticism in the history of Western literary studies by concentrating on the Feldman-Dowd dispute which took place in Beckett Studies in the 2000s. Feldman argues that the best way to increase scholarly knowledge about Beckett is via verifiable empirical evidence which allows a falsification process. Dowd questions the legitimacy of the direct application of scientific concept of falsification to literary studies; Feldman’s narrow view of authorship; and the supposed objectivity of empirical science. He also raises concern about the restrictions that his methodological standardization might incur for critical hermeneutics. Feldman’s dogmatic position is further troubled by Uhlmann’s observation of natural limits in the interpretative methods of falsifiability related to empirical evidence. Van Hulle offers a reconciliation between philological empiricism and theoretical interpretation by classifying between exogenetics and endogenetics, as does Wittgenstein by distinguishing between cause and reason.

키워드

Beckett StudiesFeldman-Dowd disputephilologytheoretical criticismfalsifiabilityscholarly responsibility

식별자

KCI
ART002497062