본문 바로가기

냉전 이후 시대의 투키디데스(c460~c400 B.C: 그리스 역사가): 신 현실주의론자 형상으로부터 고전적인 현실주의자로서의 투키디데스를 재 발견

Thucydides in the Post-Cold War Era: Recovering Thucydides as Classical Realist from Neorealist Memorialization

문서 유형
연구출판물 · 학술지 논문
등재
KCI
저널
21세기정치학회보28(1) · pp.141 · 2018
피인용
KCI 0
ISSN
1229-5167

저자

  1. 로버트 켈리제1저자부산대학교

초록

Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War is a foundational text for the field of international relations (IR). It is IR’s only textual connection to the entire tradition of classical political thought. Before Thomas Hobbes, only St. Augustine might be another candidate for a classical lineage for the field. As such Thucydides is of special importance. He connects IR to the wider Western intellectual tradition. This essays re-examines the widely used image in IR of Thucydides as a pre-cursor to modern neorealism. It argues that this is a now-dated Cold War portrait. We come to this image of Thucydides by excerpting famous passages from his History – most notably the Melian Dialogue – which de-contextualizes them, allowing an unwarranted, excessively realist portrait. Placing the Dialogue back in context of the whole text lets the reader see it as part of Athens’ decline in the war from its initial, Periclean heights to harsh brutality at Melos. The long arc of this imperial decline stands as a warning to other would-be hegemons and empire-builders. Excerpting the Dialogue as a stand-alone programmatic statement misses this and boils down Thucydides’ complexity. If we read the text as a whole, Thucydides seems far more humanist than neorealist; hence the judgment here that he is best understood as a classical realist.

키워드

RealismClassical RealismNeorealismThucydidesMelian Dialogue현실주의고전적 현실주의신현실주의투키디데스멜리안 협상

식별자

KCI
ART002334647